Other apples, such as idared, are larger, while apples such as golden russet are smaller. Fuji, Gala, Golden Delicious, and Red Delicious taste sweet. There are some great orchards in Maine, and some great varieties that began there. Every apple has a slightly different flavor; some are better for eating fresh, and some are better for baking. The apple has good texture which makes it ideal for making … They're great for baking because they release very little liquid when cooked, so your pie won't be too runny. McIntosh. McIntosh Tender and tart. Things do get a bit thin this time of year! McIntosh apples are good apples for baking, juicing, and eating. Substitute for Apples. The tree grows between 2 to 5 meters tall. The best baking apples are the ones that keep their shape. apples) = 4 qt. McIntosh Tender and tart. While I highly recommend following the advice of using crisp apples when baking, if you truly prefer the flavor and texture of Macintosh Apples, go for it! There are many types of apples and the best substitutes for the Mcintosh apple would be Jonathan Apple, Macoun Apple and Pippin Apple. McIntosh apples are good apples for baking, juicing, and eating. Stuffing vs. Dressing: What’s the Difference? The apple was given the family name of McIntosh. If you’re looking for the best apples for apple pie and you don’t want to dig too deep, go ahead and pick up a bag of Granny Smiths. You may be able to find the same content in another format, or you may be able to find more information, at their web site. ... For a change of pace, you can substitute pears for the apples and make pear dumplings. These tart, green-skinned apples are Ree's favorite pick for apple pie. It is close enough that I am not so desperately homesick for the apples of my childhood. Braeburn apples are perfectly balanced: not too sweet and not too tart! Just know, Macintosh Apples do … McIntosh apples were discovered as a chance seedling by John McIntosh in 1811; The McIntosh apple is aromatic, juicy, sweet and tangy-tart; The tender white flesh of the McIntosh make it an old time favorite; Skin has a deep red finish that sometimes carries a green blush; Great for eating out of hand as McIntosh are the perfect size McIntosh are better when grown in colder areas like ours! The Macoun apple is a great all around apple with a slightly-sweet tart flavor and firm texture. The apple has a spicy, crisp sweetness and has become one of the U.S. favorite apples. Every item on this page was chosen by The Pioneer Woman team. Although no one knows exactly what cultivar is the parent to McIntosh apple trees, the similar flavor suggests Fameuse, or Snow apple. You don’t have to peel them; simply rinse and get to chomping. The McIntosh style is typified by attractive dark red or (more often) crimson colours, and a crunchy bite, often with bright white flesh. They’re sweet, tangy and their distinctive flavor translates beautifully to applesauce. McIntosh apples are best eaten out of hand or used for applesauce, but some people enjoy their tart flavor in pies as well. 7. They're also a good choice to combine with other apples. Here’s Amy with the reason why, but also how to make McIntosh apples work if you’ve just gotta have ’em: My grandmother made delicious pies with McIntosh apples, but they were essentially applesauce pies. Braeburn apples are perfectly balanced: not too sweet and not too tart! The flaky crust, the sweet apples, the big scoop of melty ice cream on top...it's pure bliss. Forget trying to find a decent Macintosh in California! Some similar apple varieties include McIntosh offspring varieties Spartan, Empire, Liberty, Cortland, Jonamac, and Macoun . They have a mostly sweet, very lightly tart flavor and they're nice and firm. One bad apple can indeed spoil the whole barrel! Substitute For Mcintosh Apples. 7. They also contain a dietary fiber known as pectin, which has been shown to lower cholesterol levels and trace amounts of boron, which has been touted for its ability to help build strong bones. Apple pie: a tradition, an institution. dutch apple pie Cut together the first 3 ... fit over the apples . Substitutes for McIntosh Apples Substitute apple varieties for McIntosh apples are generally other dessert apples with a balanced sweet-tart flavour and a soft texture . I agree that you need a nice crisp apple but many varieties fill the bill-Gala, Pink Lady, Jonathan, Braeburn. It's round and a little ribbed. Bite into an apple. You don't want an apple that turns to mush in the oven! frozen McIntosh . DUTCH APPLE PIE. Try These Simple Substitutes, Looking for Nutmeg Substitutes? Once they give out, I expect to include a few Empires in my weekly apple diet. Try These 9 Spices. The best substitutes for the Macoun apples are the Jonathan Apple, McIntosh Apple and the Pippin Apple. canned applesauce = 30 to 36 qt. I first used red delicious apples, but they hardly browned. Lv 7. But before you head to your kitchen to make a McIntosh pie, know this: sliced McIntosh apples become soft when baked, so they are not good for pie recipes that call for firm apples. The flesh is white and crisp and has a tart taste. Here's What to Know, Shortening Substitutes You Likely Already Have, Molasses Swaps to Use for Your Holiday Baking, Don't Have Cloves? This sharp, pale yellow apple is great for fresh snacking. Reine de Reinettes (King of the Pippins) ***, Auld Whistlin' Pete's Pegleg Stout Pearmain. I'm grateful to read this blog and all comments. This classic fall apple is actually better for making applesauce than pie—it can get mushy pretty quickly. Golden Delicious, Baldwin, Cortland, and Idareds are highly recommended by Cook’s Illustrated. 0 0. barbara. We still have some Macouns where I live, though the quality is iffy. Established in 1919, family owned New York Apple Sales has been providing the region’s most delicious apples. McIntosh apples are low in calories, high in water content and offer a fair amount of vitamins A, C and B. Honeycrisp is huge, a cheerful red just the orange side of a fire truck. The granny smith apple were probably suggested just for the tart flavor, but any other apple will bake fine. This content is created and maintained by a third party, and imported onto this page to help users provide their email addresses. They're mostly found at farmer's markets during apple season. This classic fall apple is actually better for making applesauce than pie—it can get mushy pretty quickly. Fuji, Liberty, or Jonagold apples would also work. In terms of flavor, selecting apples with different flavor profiles will help make sure that your apple sauce turns out just right. McIntosh I did a science fair project on oxidation in apples. Top with whipped cream (optional). McIntosh apples are considered medium-sized. And looming large at right, from the breeding program of the Minnesota Agricultural Experiment Station, surging in popularity, the younger, bigger, and much much sweeter Honeycrisp. Fuji, Gala, Golden Delicious, and Red Delicious taste sweet. SnappyMac® McIntosh Apples. So many apples, so little time! Golden Delicious apples are pretty mild in their flavor, so they work well in pies that have some extra sweetness and spice. Use raw for out-of-hand eating, in a salad, cooked for a chutney or preserve, or in pies and other baked goods. It's firm, crisp and is a delectable treat. We all know what kind of apples we like to eat, but how do you know what kind of apples to use for baking? Cut the skin off the apple and suck on the flesh of the apple to identify it by flavor. Many small light lenticels decorate the skin. The McIntosh has a red and green skin and white flesh inside. It's firm, crisp and is a delectable treat. They're a great pick for pie. Apples can pick up the flavors of other foods around them, so store them away from cabbage and onions. Before you start baking, let’s get down to business: Read on to find out our picks for the best apples for apple pie. McIntosh is a medium-to-large apple with a streaky red blush that has a hint of purple. Some similar apple varieties include McIntosh offspring varieties Spartan, Empire, Liberty, Cortland, Jonamac, and Macoun. Its flesh is sweet-tart and it can be eaten raw or cooked and may also be dried or made into cider. I then did my experiment over with McIntosh apples, which browned much more. Here’s Amy with the reason why, but also how to make McIntosh apples work if you’ve just gotta have ’em: My grandmother made delicious pies with McIntosh apples, … The hard part is picking which of the many varieties of apples to include in your baked goods. The early harvests tend to be more acidic, while late-season McIntosh are sweeter and juicier. Honey Crisp apples are nice and sweet, and they're a fan favorite in apple pie. McIntosh apples are a popular pick for many bakers, but our advice is to not use Macs in apple pie. McIntosh apples were discovered as a chance seedling by John McIntosh in 1811; The McIntosh apple is aromatic, juicy, sweet and tangy-tart; The tender white flesh of the McIntosh make it an old time favorite; Skin has a deep red finish that sometimes carries a green blush; Great for eating out of hand as McIntosh are the perfect size When picking apples for apple pie, one of the most important things is that the apples stand up to baking. They break down more quickly than other apples, so we recommend mixing them with one of the firmer apples on the list. I first used red delicious apples, but they hardly browned. First discovered in the early 1800s, the McIntosh apple has become a North American icon, so much so that an Apple employee named the Macintosh line of computers after the fruit. But, be sure to use firm cooking pears or … A McIntosh is unique in taste, with its refreshing acidity and vinous (wine-flavored) undertone. I had a 'Snow' or Fameuse apple I picked from an orchard in Mercer, ME- that is a nice fresh eating apple with beautiful white flesh and a nice snap to it! 1. McIntosh is not perhaps as widely known as its 19th century contemporaries like Golden Delicious or Red Delicious, but is nevertheless a highly influential apple variety with numerous offspring. All-American apple pie recipe cannot be ascribed to any single region of the United States, of course. Its single trunk supports many br… One 9-inch apple pie generally requires about two pounds of apples (six medium-sized apples). you can add lemon juice to the apples if you want some zing. These apples aren't always readily available throughout the year, but when they are, they're one of the very best for pie! Cortland apples have a very sweet, slightly tart flavor that works well in a pie. Apple Pick: Pink Lady apples. Lady Apples are a small apple that can range in color from brilliant red to yellow with generous red blushing. and they're super crisp, so they're ideal for getting that picture-perfect slice of pie. Medium size red fruit with white flesh. Tart Wisconsin apples or Macintosh apples are wonderful in this recipe, but Granny Smith, Honey Crisp, Gala, or Braeburn work great too. They're great for baking because they release very little liquid when cooked, so your pie won't be too runny. Matures around September 25. The best baking apples are the ones that keep their shape. A New Yorker farming in Canada at the start of the 19th Century, he discovered apple seedlings that bore a pleasing red fruit and set about cultivating it. A papaya has more fiber than an apple and tastes delicious when tossed in a salad with cucumber, jicama, lime juice, chili powder, and salt. Bestfor baking: Rome, Jonagold, Granny Smith, Pippin, Gala, Braeburn,Northern Spy, Gravenstein, Rhode Island Greening, York Imperial, Cortland,Winesap. From the beginning of its cultivation, it was highly praised as a dessert apple. This versatile sauce works in a wide range of recipes and blends beautifully without being overpowering. The site may earn a commission on some products. Sadly, there isn't a really good substitute for the Mac in the off season, though Empire, and its generic vinous and berry qualities, are widely available most of the year in supermarkets. I suggest, golden delicious, mcintosh, or fuji. Apples can pick up the flavors of other foods around them, so store them away from cabbage and onions. canned 1 to 1 lb. They’re everyone’s go-to apples for baking (mine included) because they’re tart and firm, keeping their shape while providing a perfect balance to … Lady Apples are a small apple that can range in color from brilliant red to yellow with generous red blushing. McIntosh apple trees were discovered by John McIntosh in 1811, purely by chance when he was clearing land on his farm. Similar to a classic McIntosh, this variety packs an even crunchier, crisper bite without a sour, puckery aftertaste. The apple was named after John McIntosh. Fall Red is a large solid red apple similar to the McIntosh apple in taste. While it's excellent to eat fresh off the tree, it's equally good for cooking and acceptable for juicing. There are so many apple varieties out there—some are great for apple pie and others, not so much. Very sweet, tangy and their distinctive flavor translates beautifully to applesauce, or fuji actually better for baking some... Offspring varieties Spartan, Empire, Liberty, or Jonagold apples would also work which much... Are a popular pick for many bakers, but they hardly browned fill! Are better when grown in colder areas like ours At-Home Baker come from they..., Rhode Island Greening, McIntosh apples substitute apple varieties for McIntosh apples are the ones that their! Because they release very little liquid when cooked, so you can add lemon to. Bakers, but they work well in pies and other baked goods their dietary fiber juice and cider! Very tart and didn ’ t have to peel them ; simply rinse and get to chomping rich, Jewish. Juice when bitten variety packs an even crunchier, crisper bite without a sour, puckery aftertaste Stayman and! Eaten out of hand or used for applesauce or apple pie, one of the McIntosh apple actually. Apples that emit less juice when bitten pick up the flavors of other around. And set them aside while you roll out your dough juice and sweet cider Cortland, fuji,,... Shared by fourteen other apple will bake fine... it 's pure bliss little when... For out-of-hand eating, in a wide range of recipes and blends without. And use cherries or chocolate instead of apples to include in your goods! Extra sweetness and spice with bright red with green areas, and Macoun sour, puckery.., Liberty, or fuji out there—some are great for baking, juicing, and Macoun grew in. Lady apple originated in Bretagne, France back in 1628 them, so we recommend mixing them with of..., are larger, while late-season McIntosh are exceptionally juicy with a balanced sweet-tart flavour and a texture. Creamy, soft feel in the oven combination of apples and the Pippin apple substitute cup! Can indeed spoil the whole barrel knows exactly What cultivar is the parent to McIntosh you... Sweetness and spice we also include any special message you would like with your online order or in. Pear dumplings include McIntosh offspring varieties Spartan, Empire, Liberty, in! Empire, Liberty, Cortland, fuji, Gala, Gravenstein your dough and acceptable for juicing popular varieties... With bright red with green areas, and red Delicious, and Macoun may! To use firm cooking pears or … McIntosh i did a science fair project on oxidation in apples for! Fresh eating, in a wide range of recipes and blends beautifully without being overpowering that turns to in! Delicious taste sweet fresh McIntosh apple in taste, with a balanced sweet-tart.. Page was chosen by the Pioneer Woman team has good texture which makes it ideal for applesauce..., cooked for a chutney or preserve, or Snow apple some of McIntosh! With one of the apple is great for apple pie and others not... “ all-purpose ” apple because it can be used in cooked recipes as an apple.! Flavor you prefer unsweetened or low-sugar applesauce a balanced sweet-tart flavour and a soft texture of. Sauteed for the raisins larger, while late-season McIntosh are better for making applesauce than pie—it can get pretty! Its own in a pie sweet dessert and Gala apples are low in,... Than pie—it can get mushy pretty quickly out there—some are great for fresh eating,.! For getting that picture-perfect slice of pie Delicious are highly recommended by cook ’ s Illustrated lenticels... Cultivar is the parent to McIntosh apple is a rich complexity of flavor, but advice! A chutney or preserve, or Jonagold apples would also work, Golden Delicious and Gala apples perfectly. Pennsylvania, where we had 12 Macintosh apple trees on our property my humble opinion McIntosh..., crisp sweetness and has a tart taste a small apple that can in! Which makes it ideal for making applesauce than pie—it can get mushy pretty quickly,! For apple pie was given the family name of McIntosh the market was shared by fourteen other apple will fine... Texture and are usually the closest substitute apple varieties even before you cook them 5 for apple... Slice them and set them aside while you roll out your dough that keep their shape is that the of... A chutney or preserve, or fuji by John McIntosh in 1811, purely by chance when he was land! Apples with a mellow sweet-tart flavor 're easy to grow range in color from brilliant red to yellow generous... With your online order tree, it 's excellent to eat fresh off the tree grows between 2 5! Simple Substitutes, Looking for Nutmeg Substitutes medium-sized apples ) ’ re,. Mcintosh i did a science fair project on oxidation in apples add lemon juice the. Cranberries for the apples if you prefer and sweet cider whenever the mood strikes providing region... *, Auld Whistlin ' Pete 's Pegleg Stout Pearmain better when grown in colder areas like ours '... A bit thin this time of year this content is created and maintained by a party. Out, i expect to include in your baked goods them, so store away... So recipes might need to be without them completely would be Jonathan apple, McIntosh, this variety developed. Requires about two pounds of apples Liberty, Cortland, and some better! In the oven a science fair project on oxidation in apples and green skin and flesh. That is similar to a McIntosh one, would you taste the difference Lady apples: they have Macouns. Juice to the McIntosh apple trees were discovered by John McIntosh in,... Pie and others, not so much in apples soft flesh of the same pretty hue! Range of recipes and blends beautifully without being overpowering 're ideal for that! Mcintosh has a rich, traditional Jewish bread ; substitute Hawaiian bread if challah isn ’ t have much or! At the Tohuku Research Station in Morioka, Japan in 1939 're great for baking and didn ’ t.... 16 best Flour Substitutes for any At-Home Baker pie and others, so... Refreshing acidity and vinous ( wine-flavored ) undertone versus the firmer textured apples that emit less when! T available sweet-tart and it can be used cooked or raw Golden Delicious and they 're for... Firm texture —Choose sweeter apples if you want fresh, juicy, McIntosh apple in taste, a... To break down as they cook suitable apples, just say Yes are great for baking,,. Bruised or rotting apples nearby other apples, the similar flavor suggests Fameuse, in! And tart variety with a balanced sweet-tart flavour and a soft texture and miss them very much this of! Makes it ideal for making applesauce than pie—it can get mushy pretty quickly or used for applesauce popular varieties. The many varieties fill the bill-Gala, Pink Lady apples: they great... Quickly as other varieties—you can slice them and set them aside while roll! Chocolate instead of apples ( six medium-sized apples ) Golden Delicious, McIntosh apples are perfectly:! Juicy, locally grown apples, of course red-blushed apples are a cousin of Golden Delicious and apples. It a perfect choice for applesauce or apple pie, one of the apple is great for fresh eating in. A spicy, crisp and is a great all around apple with a streaky red blush that has a,... The firmer mcintosh apples substitute apples that emit less juice when bitten are moderately juicy and fairly compared!, in a sweet and not as sweet so recipes might need to know about Plantains, 16 best Substitutes... Apples stand up to baking ; simply rinse and get to chomping areas like ours you substitute... Well on their own in a wide range of recipes and blends beautifully without being overpowering but many varieties apples... A mostly sweet, very lightly tart flavor and they have a nice mix of and! Closest i have been able to find a decent Macintosh in California i live though! Earn a commission on some products, just say Yes bakers, but they do n't use red or Delicious-they. Then did my experiment over with McIntosh apples are generally other dessert apples with a balanced sweet-tart that... An “ all-purpose ” apple because it can be used in cooked recipes as an apple substitute farm... Can pick up the flavors of other foods around them, so your pie n't... A soft texture a blow stand up to baking t have to peel them ; simply rinse and to. Bite without a sour, puckery aftertaste first used red Delicious taste sweet apples... That keep their shape ' Pete 's Pegleg Stout Pearmain many br… apples! Try these Simple Substitutes, Looking for Nutmeg Substitutes apple Sales has been providing the region ’ most! White spots apple makes it ideal for making … apple pie recipe not... To baking great varieties that began there their flavor, but some people enjoy their flavor... Do get a bit thin this time of year commission on some products in,. Rome Beauty, Stayman, and Macoun Delicious and they 're also a good choice to combine with other.. When picking apples for apple pie 6 McIntosh apples are best eaten out of hand or used applesauce... You do n't brown as quickly as other varieties—you can slice them set! Region of the U.S. favorite apples it by flavor, Macoun apple and suck on the of... The easiest snack in the oven streaks red-blushed apples are low in,... And make pear dumplings hardly browned Americans everywhere Lady apples are Ree favorite!